Independent Contractor vs. Self-Employed: What You Need to Know

Not all self-employed people are independent contractors. Learn what an independent contractor is and what "self-employed" means, and 4 things non-employees must have when working for you.

Woman reading a book, seated at an office table with skyscrapers behind her

Plane Team

Published on May 16, 2022

All apples are fruit, but not all fruit are apples. That’s essentially the difference between independent contractors and self-employed workers. All independent contractors are self-employed, but not all self-employed people are independent contractors. For hiring purposes, you treat them the same: You don’t employ contractors; they technically employ themselves. However, contractors and self-employed people are not exactly the same thing. When working with both, you need to keep certain legal and tax compliance concerns in mind in order to protect your business and your workers.

What is an independent contractor?

An independent contractor is someone contracted by an individual or company to provide a service. Contractors, or freelancers, tend to be highly skilled in specific fields, often found in such industries as law, accounting, writing, art, programming, construction, and more. First things first: Contractors aren’t employees. In the United States, there are three key differences between contractors and employees, according to the Internal Revenue Service:
  1. Behavioral control: How they work, including when and where. While contractors dictate how, where, and when they work, employees don’t typically have that freedom. When working with contractors, the payer can only control the result — the “what” — and not the means — the “how.”
  2. Financial control: How they get paid, i.e., how much, how regularly, and through what means. Contractors generally dictate how they would like to be paid and how much. Employees are paid based on the employer’s payroll schedule and budget.
  3. Relationship: A combination of factors, including the wording of any written contracts, the length and permanency of the work relationship, as well as whether benefits are provided. For example, employees generally receive benefits like healthcare and paid time off while contractors do not.
Misclassification is a real concern when working with contractors. Make sure that your contractors really are contractors and not employees misclassified as such. For more info on the differences, check out our Guide on Who to Hire: Contractor vs. Full-Time Employee.Contractors are often hired to fill short-term needs or complete project-based work, with the scope of work clearly defined in their written contract. For example, a social media specialist could be contracted to craft and schedule 10 posts by the end of each week for $2,000 a month.According to the IRS, “If you are a business owner or contractor who provides services to other businesses, then you are generally considered self-employed.” This is because even though independent contractors are paid by an employer, they technically work for themselves.

What does “self-employed” mean?

Being self-employed means that someone earns income by working for themselves instead of for an employer. Even if they’re paid by various people or entities, self-employed people must find their own work, without being guaranteed a regular salary.There are three common business structures that self-employed people tend to use when running their own businesses in the U.S.:
  1. Sole proprietorship: The owner, or sole proprietor, is the business. The business is unincorporated, owned, and operated by one person. Their business income is considered personal income. Independent contractors and freelancers fall into this category.
  2. Partnership: Two or more parties share ownership of a business. They divide its liabilities, responsibilities, and profits.
  3. Limited liability company (LLC): A business entity that has one or more owners, called “members.” All members of the LLC are protected from personal liability for debts or legal issues.
Self-employed business owners manage their business expenses, including wages for any employees or contractors they choose to hire. Self-employed individuals are also in charge of calculating tax liability and paying their own taxes on time — quarterly for those owing over $1,000 per year. This includes a self-employment tax, paid in lieu of FICA tax (Social Security and Medicare taxes), as well as federal income tax and state income tax. They may also owe business taxes, depending on the scale of their small business.Workers enjoy being self-employed thanks to the independence of being their own boss and the freedom to choose their own work hours. There’s also no limit to the potential income self-employed people can earn versus a fixed salary they would earn as an employee. On the flip side, self-employed people have to motivate themselves to work and actively seek out opportunities because pay isn’t guaranteed. They can also run into tax issues when filing their tax returns, especially if they don’t work with an accountant. Additionally, self-employed people don’t receive employee benefits like health insurance, paid time off, and sick leave.

Independent contractor vs. self-employed individual examples

Remember our apples-to-fruit analogy? Maybe food isn’t the best comparison. Let’s look at more relevant examples that could help you figure out whether you’re working with a contractor or a self-employed person.Lawyer A is a semi-retired attorney who works on cases on an as-needed or temporary basis. She has over 30 years of experience in family law. She primarily serves as an “of counsel” attorney for law firms that occasionally consult her for her family law expertise. Lawyer A is an independent contractor. Lawyer B is a partner at a law firm. His firm seeks out and works with multiple clients year-round. He employs several associate attorneys to spread out the workload. The law firm publishes radio and TV ad spots to draw in more business. Lawyer B is self-employed.Artist A takes on occasional graphic design commissions on a contractual basis. He mainly accepts one-time projects here and there to design logos for various clients. He also works with clients for three months or more at a time to deliver more comprehensive graphic design packages. Artist A is an independent contractor.Artist B works on digital art full time and is a small business owner. She streams the art process on Twitch, earning subscriber and tip revenue from that platform, and posts the art on social media for marketing. She also operates an online storefront, from which she packs and ships print orders to customers. Artist B is self-employed.

4 things non-employees must have when working for you

When working with non-employees like contractors and self-employed workers, make sure you have a written contract, deliver all tax documents on time, and that you verify insurance and licensing requirements. These requirements may vary by country, so make sure to double-check which ones apply to the country you’re hiring in. These things will ensure that your business and its contractors are compliant with legal and tax regulations. These compliance concerns are the same whether someone is an independent contractor or self-employed.

1. A contract

Your employment contract details the relationship between you and your non-employee. It protects you both and spells out all the details of the work you’ll accomplish together.In your contract, define the scope of work. Specify the results or the deliverables you expect to receive from your contractor, as well as deadlines. Include the rate of compensation — usually determined by the contractor — and explain how you’ll pay them. You should also clarify their employment status, including the fact that they are a contractor, not an employee of your company. Define the length of your working relationship, whether it’s a one-time project or an ongoing engagement.For sensitive and classified projects, consider a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) or intellectual property transfer clause. Such clauses can ensure that your business trade secrets remain safe, and the work done by your contractor stays with the company. Since contractors use their own equipment and operate at their own cost, clarify whether or not they’ll receive reimbursement for business expenses, mileage, etc. Keep in mind that self-employed people can claim these expenses as tax deductions. You may also consider inserting a clause about termination. If either you or the contractor wishes to end your working relationship, this clause will outline how to do so.As contracts are legally binding documents, we recommend getting your contract reviewed by an employment lawyer. They can help you make sure it’s compliant with labor laws, especially if hiring across state lines or internationally. At Pilot, we have our clients’ contracts reviewed by both U.S. and local lawyers.

2. Licenses

The licenses self-employed people are required to hold depend on the work they perform and where your business is located. If they live in another state or country, the licensing requirements might be different. Common professions that require licenses include:
  • Cosmetology
  • Accountancy
  • Medical fields
  • Real estate
  • Law
  • Social work
  • Education
It’s best to check with the state and/or local governing agency for an industry to find out which licenses are required in your area. Check with each non-employee to see what licenses or certifications they have and ask for proof of their license. In the U.S., you can then verify those provided license numbers through your state’s license database. Find your state here.

3. Insurance

Any self-employed workers who aren't in an LLC have personal liability while completing their work. That's why it’s important to confirm whether or not they have business insurance. You can require your non-employees to have insurance via a clause in your employment contract.There are many different types of insurance that small businesses and self-employed individuals can purchase. General liability insurance protects businesses from lawsuits accusing them of harming another party. Among other things, this covers bodily injury, copyright infringement, property damage, slander, and libel. Professional liability insurance, also known as errors and omissions insurance, covers any mistakes made in someone’s work. This includes breaches of contract that could damage a client. Other kinds of insurance often carried by contractors, depending on their needs, include commercial auto insurance, commercial property insurance, and cyber liability insurance.Some insurance types are more applicable or necessary than others for certain business owners, depending on the profession. For example, consider a freelance copywriter who works from their home office. They probably don’t need general liability insurance to protect themselves from the risk of injury on the job. However, they may want professional liability insurance in case something they write harms their client’s reputation.By U.S. law, self-employed people generally only need to have workers’ compensation if they employ others. However, if your uninsured contractors are injured on the job, you could be held responsible for their medical bills in some states. That’s why it’s important to make sure that your contractors have insurance and show you proof of insurance before beginning work.

4. Tax forms

Make sure you provide non-employees with the IRS forms they need on time or early when possible. If you fail to provide 1099s on time to your contractors or provide an incorrect 1099, you could face costly penalties. For example, most 1099 forms are due to recipients by January 31 each tax year, but sending 1099s earlier helps keep you ahead of any fines.Start by requiring a W-9 from any non-employee before you start working together. This will provide the information you need to fill out 1099s. For international contractors you work with, request they fill out a W-8 BEN instead of a W-9. Hold onto that W-8 BEN. This form will protect your business from tax audits because you can prove that the contractor didn’t owe taxes to the United States.Keep records of the total payments sent to a contractor throughout the tax year. Then, at the end of the year, be sure to fill out and send each of your contractors a Form 1099-MISC or Form 1099-NEC (the 1099 each contractor needs will depend on the nature of their work). Because self-employed individuals need to file their own tax returns, they need the information on those 1099 forms to file their Schedule C with the IRS.

Legal Disclaimer:

The information contained in this site is provided for informational purposes only, and should not be construed as legal advice on any subject matter.

Simplify hiring non-employees through Pilot

Working with non-employees may sound complicated, but it doesn’t have to be. We’ve got you covered — from drafting a locally compliant contract to automatically paying your non-employees on time. Pilot also automates W-8 BEN and W-9 requests and sends 1099-NEC forms to your contractors on time. Try Pilot today, and find out how we can help you manage your non-employee relationships more simply and painlessly.

Going global isn't daunting when you partner with Pilot. 🤝

Book a FREE, no-obligation demo with one of our experts now.

Schedule a demo

Related articles

From startups to large corporations, US companies of all sizes use Pilot for international payroll, benefits and compliance.

Want industry news and product updates?Sign up for our newsletter.